How To Tell If Pumpkin Pie Is No Good

How To Tell If Pumpkin Pie Is Done – The Signs To Look For

People who don’t know much about cooking can still feel accomplished by making a pumpkin pie.

With premade pie crusts and canned pumpkin, most pumpkin pie recipes require just five ingredients.

We who struggle with baking cookies can at least contribute to a family meal without becoming comedians by making pumpkin pie.

But how do we know when pumpkin pie is past its time? Let’s talk about it.

How To Tell If Pumpkin Pie Is Done

With the classic knife test, you can determine whether your pumpkin pie is done. Insert a sharp, thin knife into the center of the pie. Your pie is ready if there is no residue left on the knife.

The Knife Test

Indentation testing has only one downside – the knife leaves an indentation on the filling where it made contact with it. Do you mind?

A crack indicates that the pumpkin pie is truly homemade.

When you buy a pumpkin pie at the store or buy a large number of pumpkin pies, it is unlikely that it will crack, so consider it an honor!

Even so, if you cannot let it go, throw whipped cream on top of your pumpkin pie.

The cracks in a baked pie can be covered with pastry cutouts.

Testing With A Thermometer

Can pumpkin pie be tested for temperature?

Yes, you can use a meat thermometer to check if the pie is safe to eat.

An internal temperature of 180 degrees Fahrenheit is ideal for pumpkin pie when at its coldest point.

Testing With A Jiggle

Pumpkin pies don’t need to be cracked or punched if you want to know if they’re done.

Shake the pie gently to check if it’s ready: The pie should jiggle slightly in the middle when it’s ready, but there should not be any liquid in it at all.

If you do not want to break the filling, you should use this test.

Can Pumpkin Pie Be Overcooked?

Certainly. Overbaking pumpkin pie is possible; also, remember that custard pies (including pumpkin pie) continue baking after being removed from the oven.

Thus, it is very important to set your timer appropriately for the minimum baking time given and check your pumpkin pie as soon as the buzzer sounds, regardless of which pumpkin pie test you choose to conduct.

If you notice bubbling and separation between the crust and the filling about the pie’s edges, this is a sign that it has been overcooked.

If either occurs, take the pie out of the oven right away.

Ensure that the pie crust edges do not over-brown.

Use aluminum foil, or you can buy commercial piecrust shields to protect the edges.

Cook’s Tip: Allow your pie to cool completely after it has been baked according to the recipe.

Cool for 1 hour, then cover and chill for 2 hours.

I would recommend not serving a pumpkin pie that is still warm.

This will make it mushy. Pumpkin pie is also better when it is cold and firm than warm and gooey.

Can An Undercook Pie Be Fixed?

Undercooked pies should be covered with aluminum foil and baked at 425 F for about 15 minutes (or as long as necessary). Before cooling, test the pies for doneness. Add whipped cream if desired.

Put the oven back on

If your oven dial is not accurate, use an oven thermometer.

Bake the pie at 350 degrees for about 20 minutes.

If the edges are getting too dark, cover it with aluminum foil to avoid burning the cake.

Undercooked pumpkin pie: Is it the oven’s fault? Several ovens display wrong temperatures and/or do not heat evenly. These are bad ovens! 

After cooling, place a dollop of whipped cream on top

It only takes a little whipped cream to make everything right.

When making pumpkin pie, it can be a challenge to achieve just the right level of doneness.

Overcooking can cause cracking in fillings.


Once you learn how to check pumpkin pie for readiness, you can prepare the easiest and best fall dessert ever. Go ahead and experiment!

The internet is the best place to find a never-ending supply of pumpkin pie recipes.

So it never gets boring and pumpkin pie is always a nice dessert for colder days.

Frequently Asked Questions about Pumpkin Pie

Can I Get Sick From Undercooked Pie?

Pie with raw eggs can make you ill if it’s undercooked. Food poisoning can occur from consuming raw or uncooked eggs, which may contain pathogens such as Salmonella. Egg contamination risk is low, but it can occur.

When It Cools Does Pumpkin Pie Thicken?

Cooling will firm up the pumpkin pie’s center. Make sure the pie doesn’t get too stiff by baking it too long. The center of the pie should barely jiggle when you insert a knife.